Cimarron Model P Pre-War 357 Magnum 4.75in Blued Revolver – 6 Rounds

Frt 15 is a Houston, TX-based retailer specializing in firearms and accessories for families and responsible shooters. The Cimarron Model P Pre-War 357 Magnum 4.75in Blued Revolver is a faithful single-action reproduction of the classic 1873 Colt Peacemaker. This revolver stands out with its authentic pre-war styling and robust .357 Magnum chambering, offering a direct link to the Old West with modern versatility. It’s in stock and ready to ship today for $512.99 (regularly $569.99).

Who Is This Cimarron Model P For? (And Who Should Look Elsewhere)

After years on the range and teaching families, I see three main types of shooters who will connect with this revolver. First, the history buff or cowboy action shooter who values authenticity. This isn’t a modern polymer pistol; it’s a piece of living history you can shoot. Second, the recreational shooter looking for a pure, uncomplicated range experience. There’s a unique satisfaction in mastering the single-action mechanics. Third, the home defender in a rural setting who appreciates the sheer reliability and power of a wheelgun. The .357 Magnum load is no joke.

On the other hand, this isn’t your gun if you need a high-capacity, tactical sidearm for competitive speed shooting or concealed carry. The manual of arms is deliberate, and reloading takes practice. If that’s your primary need, you’d be better served by a modern semi-auto in our full shop.

What You Get: Key Features of the Cimarron Model P

1. Authentic Pre-War Profile: Cimarron nailed the details. The hammer, trigger, and frame have the correct, rounded contours of the original 1st Generation Colts produced before 1896. For a collector or enthusiast, these subtle curves make all the difference compared to later, bulkier post-war models.
2. Versatile .357 Magnum/.38 Special Chambering: This is a huge practical advantage. You can practice all day with soft-shooting, affordable .38 Special rounds, then load potent .357 Magnum for serious work. It’s like having two guns in one, a point I always stress to new shooters learning about recoil management.
3. Classic Case-Hardened Frame & Blued Steel Finish: The color case hardening on the frame isn’t just paint; it’s a heat-treating process that creates those distinctive blues, purples, and golds while adding surface hardness. The blued barrel and cylinder have a deep, rich luster that looks right out of a saddlebag.
4. 4.75″ “Cavalry” Length Barrel: This barrel length hits a sweet spot. It’s historically accurate for a belt pistol, offers a good sight radius for improved accuracy, and keeps the overall balance and weight manageable. It draws smoothly from a holster and points naturally.
5. Six-Round Cylinder with Traditional Loading Gate: The process of loading one round at a time through the gate, rotating the cylinder, and then lowering the loading lever might seem slow, but it forces a discipline and rhythm that many shooters, especially youth I’ve coached, find meditative and rewarding.
6. Solid Steel Construction: There’s zero plastic on this firearm. The heft in your hand is substantial and reassuring. This build quality translates directly to durability and longevity—this is a gun you can pass down.

How It Stacks Up: Cimarron vs. The Competition

The table tells the story. The Cimarron Model P occupies that crucial middle ground—far surpassing the budget options in quality and authenticity without demanding the premium custom shop price. For most shooters, it’s the most gun for the dollar.

Technical Specifications

The Honest Breakdown: Pros & Cons

What I like about it:

• ✅ Authentic Feel & Shootability: The balance and pointability are exactly what you want from a single-action. It makes you a more deliberate shooter.
• ✅ Dual-Caliber Flexibility: The .357/.38 Special chambering is a massive practical benefit for cost-effective training and powerful application.
• ✅ Superior Fit & Finish: For its price point, the polish, bluing, and case coloring are outstanding. It looks and feels like a more expensive firearm.
• ✅ Proven Design & Durability: The 1873 action is simple, strong, and incredibly reliable. With basic care, this revolver will outlast its owner.
• ✅ Historical Connection: This isn’t just a tool; it’s an experience. Handling and shooting it provides a tangible link to the past.

What you should consider:

• ❌ Deliberate Manual of Arms: Loading and unloading is a process. It’s not fast. If you need rapid reloads, this isn’t the platform. Consider a modern revolver or semi-auto from our shop.
• ❌ Fixed Sights: The sights are traditional and non-adjustable. You file the front sight to adjust point of impact. This is authentic but less convenient than modern adjustable sights.
• ❌ Weight & Size: It’s a solid steel gun. It’s not light or small, making it a dedicated range, hunting, or home gun, not a concealed carry piece.

Your Questions, Answered

This Cimarron Model P Pre-War revolver is more than just a firearm; it’s a working piece of American history. It offers a shooting experience that modern polymer pistols simply can’t match—one of craftsmanship, rhythm, and power. If you’re looking for that authentic single-action feel, the versatility of .357/.38, and quality that will last, this is your revolver.

Browse more: Accessories | Full Shop