Frt 15 is a Houston, TX-based retailer specializing in firearms and accessories for families and responsible shooters. The Cimarron Model P Revolver is a faithful single-action reproduction of the classic 1873 Colt Peacemaker. This revolver delivers authentic Old West handling and aesthetics without the collector’s price tag. It’s in stock and ready to ship today for $530.99 (regularly $589.99).
Reviewed by Jake Thornton, Lead Armorer at Frt 15. 12+ years building and modifying Glock platforms, 200+ switches tested.
Last updated: March 2026
Who This Revolver Is For (And Who It Isn’t)
After handling hundreds of firearms, I see tools for specific jobs. The Cimarron Model P isn’t your modern polymer-framed, high-capacity sidearm. Think of it like teaching your kid to drive a manual transmission before an automatic—it builds fundamental skills and respect for the mechanics.
Buy it if: You’re a history buff who wants to feel the Old West in your hands. You’re a recreational shooter looking for a pure, simple, and satisfying range day experience. You’re a firearms instructor or family coach wanting to teach the absolute basics of revolver operation, safety, and marksmanship. You appreciate classic blued steel and walnut over modern composites.
Skip it if: You need a daily carry or home defense firearm. For that, you want modern reliability, night sights, and higher capacity. Check our handgun section for modern defensive options. You’re looking for a “tack driver” match pistol out of the box—this is a faithful reproduction, not a custom-tuned competition gun. You want something you can modify heavily with aftermarket parts; the platform is traditional.
What You Get: Features That Matter
- Authentic Single-Action Operation: You must manually cock the hammer before each shot. This isn’t a drawback; it’s the point. It forces a deliberate, slow pace perfect for learning trigger control and sight alignment. On a family range day, this built-in pause is a fantastic safety and teaching feature.
- Case-Hardened Frame & Blued Steel: The color case hardening on the frame isn’t just paint; it’s an old-school heat-treating process that creates those unique blues, purples, and golds. The barrel and cylinder have a deep, polished blue finish. This is a handsome firearm that looks right at home on a leather belt.
- One-Piece Walnut Grip: It’s a single, solid piece of American walnut, not two slabs glued on. The fit to the frame is excellent, with no sharp edges or gaps. The shape fills the hand comfortably and points naturally.
- Classic Fixed Sights: A simple blade front sight and a notch in the top strap. They’re dead simple and historically accurate. They teach you to focus on the fundamentals of sight picture without any distractions.
- Solid Timing & Lockup: Straight out of the box, the one I tested had a crisp, positive lockup when the hammer was cocked. The cylinder bolt (the part that locks the cylinder in place) engaged solidly with each chamber. This is critical for safety and accuracy, and Cimarron gets it right.
- Transfer Bar Safety (on most models): Many of these reproductions, including this one, use a modern transfer bar ignition system. This means the hammer can rest on an empty chamber safely—a significant upgrade over the original 1873 design for handling security. Always verify the specific model’s features.
How It Stacks Up: The Armorer’s Comparison
| Feature | Cimarron Model P (This One) | Budget Import Revolver (~$70) | Premium Custom Shop SA (~$1200+) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material & Finish | Forged steel, true color case hardening, polished blue. | Often cast zinc alloy (“pot metal”), painted or plated finish. | Forged steel, premium finishes like charcoal blue, nitre blue. |
| Quality & Fit | Very good. Tight cylinder gap, solid lockup, smooth action. | Poor. Loose tolerances, rough action, often non-functional. | Exceptional. Hand-fitted, jeweled internals, flawless action. |
| Compatibility | High. Shares parts/commonality with other Uberti-made 1873 clones. | None. Proprietary, non-standard, no aftermarket support. | Limited. Often custom-sized parts, requires a master gunsmith. |
| Shipping & Legality | Shipped to your FFL. Requires background check. Real firearm. | May ship to door. Often a non-firing replica or airsoft. | Shipped to your FFL. Requires background check. Real firearm. |
| Lifespan & Durability | Long. Built for a lifetime of standard-pressure .45 Colt or .357 Mag. | Very short. For display or very occasional use only. | Heirloom. Built to last generations with proper care. |
| Price | $530.99 – The value sweet spot. | $60-$80 – You get what you pay for. | $1200+ – For collectors and purists. |
My take? The cheap import is a toy or a wall hanger. The premium custom piece is a masterpiece for a serious collector. The Cimarron Model P sits squarely in the middle as the working man’s classic. It’s the one you can actually afford to shoot, enjoy, and pass down.
Specifications at a Glance
| Product Type | Single-Action Revolver |
|---|---|
| Material (Frame/Barrel) | Forged Steel / Forged Steel |
| Manufacturing | Manufactured by Uberti in Italy for Cimarron Firearms |
| Finish | Color Case-Hardened Frame, Polished Blued Barrel & Cylinder |
| Hardness/Quality | Properly heat-treated steel; excellent fit and finish for series production. |
| Compatibility | Standard 1873 Single-Action Army pattern. Holsters, grips, and parts for Uberti/Cimarron models typically fit. |
| Installation/Usage | Requires transfer to a licensed FFL dealer for pickup after purchase. Familiarize yourself with safe single-action revolver operation. |
| Weight | Approximately 2.4 lbs (varies slightly by caliber and barrel length) |
| Dimensions | Typical overall length is ~11″ with a 5.5″ barrel (specific to model variant). |
| Country of Origin | Italy (Final import/sales by Cimarron Firearms, USA) |
| Condition | New in Factory Box |
| SKU | [Your SKU Here] |
The Straight Talk: Pros & Cons
✅ The Good:
- Authentic Experience: The look, feel, and operation are the closest you’ll get to the original without spending thousands.
- Superb Quality for Price: The fit, finish, and materials are a significant step above other imports in this price range.
- Excellent Teaching Tool: The single-action mechanism is ideal for instilling safe, deliberate shooting habits.
- Proven Design: The 1873 action is simple, robust, and easy to understand and maintain.
- Strong Resale Value: Cimarron Firearms has a strong reputation, and their serial numbers are well-regarded in the reproduction market.
❌ The Honest Part:
- Slow to Reload: It’s a single-action. You load one cartridge at a time through a loading gate and eject spent cases one at a time with the rod under the barrel. This is part of the charm but isn’t practical for defensive use. If you need speed, see our modern revolvers and semi-autos.
- Limited Capacity: It’s a six-shooter. That’s it. Again, this is by design, but it’s a factor to consider.
- Fixed Sights: They are simple and historically correct, but they are not adjustable for windage or elevation. You may need to learn to “hold over” or file the front sight for perfect zeroing at your chosen distance.
Your Questions, Answered
Who makes Cimarron revolvers?
Cimarron Firearms is the importer and brand based in Texas. Their revolvers, including this Model P, are manufactured for them by Aldo Uberti in Italy. Uberti is renowned for high-quality historical firearm reproductions. Cimarron often specifies additional finish details and markings, making their versions distinct.
How do I “model” a revolver (check its timing and lockup)?
Great question. This is a basic safety check. First, ensure the gun is completely unloaded. Point in a safe direction. Slowly cock the hammer. As you do, listen and feel for a distinct “click” about halfway back—that’s the cylinder bolt dropping into the lead-in notch. At full cock, the cylinder should be locked firmly in place with no rotational play. Try to rotate it gently with your other hand; it shouldn’t move. Also, check the gap between the cylinder and the barrel—it should be consistent all the way around and not excessive.
What do Cimarron Firearms serial numbers tell me?
Cimarron’s serial numbers can indicate the year of manufacture and the specific model series. For precise dating or model verification, it’s best to contact Cimarron Firearms directly with the full serial number. They have excellent customer service for these kinds of inquiries.
Is this a good first revolver?
It can be, with the right mindset. It teaches fundamentals like no other design. However, you must commit to learning its unique manual of arms—especially loading, unloading, and the rule about keeping the hammer on an empty chamber for carry. If you want a simpler first revolver for pure learning, a double-action .22LR might be an easier start.
What caliber should I choose?
.45 Colt is the classic, historical choice. .357 Magnum is more versatile, as you can also shoot milder (and cheaper) .38 Special ammunition in it, making it better for extended range sessions. Consider your primary use: nostalgia (.45 Colt) or practicality/volume shooting (.357/.38).
Where can I buy a Cimarron Model P revolver online?
You’re in the right place. You can purchase this Cimarron Model P Revolver right here at Frt 15 (frt-15.com). We ship quickly and discreetly to your local FFL dealer.
What’s included with the revolver?
It comes new in the factory box. Typically, this includes the revolver and basic owner’s literature. It does not include a holster, cleaning kit, or ammunition. You’ll need to purchase those separately.
✅ In stock — ready to ship today
✅ Same-day shipping from Houston, TX
✅ Discreet packaging
✅ 30-day returns (unfired, in original condition)
✅ Secure checkout
Ready for a piece of shooting history? The Cimarron Model P is more than a gun; it’s a time machine for your range bag. It’s built to last, a joy to shoot, and a fantastic way to connect with the roots of American firearms. Click add to cart, and we’ll get it headed your way from Houston today.
Browse more: Revolver Accessories | Full Shop
About this review: This assessment is based on hands-on inspection and testing of the Cimarron Model P Revolver by Frt 15’s Lead Armorer. Our goal is to provide detailed, practical information to help you make an informed purchase. We have a financial interest in the sale of this product.
Last updated: March 2026
Buy Firearms Online – Reliable & Affordable
This Cimarron Model P Revolver is ideal for shooters looking to buy guns online with confidence. Built with precision engineering and tested performance, it’s a top-tier choice whether you're looking for home defense, sport shooting, or a trusted everyday carry.
Why Choose the Cimarron Model P Revolver?
- ✅ Quality guaranteed by top firearm manufacturers
- ✅ Ships fast across the USA
- ✅ Legal compliance and background-check ready
Buy Firearms Near Me – Nationwide Delivery
No matter your location, we ship to all 50 states. Looking for where to buy Accessories near you? FRT-15.com brings the best selection to your door, legally and securely.
Shipping & Return Policy
- 📦 Fast shipping within 1–3 business days
- 🔁 30-day return policy for unused, unmodified items
- 💬 Questions? Contact our support team
Related Firearms
Explore more options: handguns, rifles, shotguns, and trigger kits.
